How to Identify Valuable Pieces In Your Jewelry Box

identify valuable pieces in your jewelry box
Yingjia Puk

By Yingjia Puk | Jun 24th, 2021

Is your jewelry box filled with items passed down from family, and perhaps with pieces you no longer wear? Whether you’re a collector or inheritor, the items in your jewelry box can be a treasure trove of surprises. Jewel-encrusted items we think may be extremely valuable can be worth only a few dollars; while something like a simple chain may be worth thousands.

If you’ve ever scored a great deal for a shiny bauble at a flea market or found a lost ring, you probably know that feeling of excitement and curiosity. While the sentimental value of jewelry is priceless- how can you determine if that sparkly ring in your hand is a precious treasure, or a cheap trinket?

Look for stamps and hallmarks

These markings are usually located on the inside of a ring or bracelet, the post of an earring, or on the clasp of a necklace. If the piece is stamped, it will generally list the metal content of a piece, such as the gold karat purity. And if there are other markings present, may show a designer’s signature, manufacturer logo, or the country of origin. Unless the hallmarks have worn off from years of wear, all fine jewelry should have some type of stamp.

Here are some common fineness stamps for precious metals:

Round cut stud earrings
Round cut stud earrings sold at auction for $2,484.

Some collectible fine jewelry maker’s marks include Van Cleef & Arpels, Cartier, and Tiffany & Co. Items containing these stamps should be appraised for authenticity. There’re a multitude of maker’s marks and hallmarks; the fact that your jewelry is stamped, can help give clues to its identity and value.

Cartier Love Bracelet
Cartier Love Bracelet sold at auction for $3,820.

If the piece looks antique, is not stamped, and heavier than expected- it may be worth checking out. However if the item looks new but does not have any markings at all, it is likely costume jewelry.Sell Your Jewelry

Identify the material: is it fine or costume?

The value of gold or platinum is determined by the percentage content and weight, regardless of design. Any diamonds and semi-precious stones in the piece have a going market value. Most costume jewelry have insignificant value in materials, but subjective factors such as maker and age may create value in certain collector markets.

Gold Necklace
22K gold necklace sold at auction for $2,250. Metal Weight (g): 69.85.

This is particularly important when you’re assessing items like chains and bangles. Generally gold and silver are heavier metals than non-precious metals like brass and pewter. For instance, if you have two similar looking gold chains with very different weights, one chain is likely fake or made of hollow gold links. Solid gold and platinum pieces have a significant heft to them.

Round cut solitaire ring
Platinum custom made GIA 0.71 CT round cut solitaire ring sold at auction for $1,319.

Metal in costume pieces are usually a gold or silver colored plating over a (non-precious) base metal such as copper, aluminum or brass. If you see a darker or silvery color showing through parts of a gold chain that see heavy wear -and if parts of it are discolored or flaking off- this is likely a gold-plated chain. When solid gold or platinum jewelry wears down, the part showing through should still be consistent with the original color. This is not the case for white gold, which is usually rhodium plated to give it a whiter, brighter finish.

Not all gems are created equal

Look closely at colorless gems. Modern diamond cuts are very precise but older cuts can be less symmetrical and defined. As for colored gemstones such as rubies, sapphires and emeralds; antique gems are often untreated, making them more sought after. Keep an eye out for stones with good transparency, and strong, bright colors.

Ruby earrings
Ruby earrings sold at auction for $1,263.

Additionally it’s a good idea to check how the gemstones are set. Are they glued onto the piece, or held in place by an intricate setting? Fine jewelry is well-crafted, with each stone clad by prongs, bezel, tension, or channel set mountings. Look inside and at the back, the best jewelry should have an excellent finish on all surfaces of the piece.

Round cut diamond tennis bracelet
Round cut diamond tennis bracelet with prong setting, sold at auction for $2,872.

Some higher quality costume jewelry uses prongs just like fine jewelry. That’s when weight, hallmarks, and examining the finish, can help shed some light on the identity of a jewel.

Consult an expert

While your jewelry box may be filled with heirloom pieces which are cherished and passed down; it is also likely to contain pieces not to your taste. Jewelry fads go in and out of style. Just because they’re not fashionable now, doesn’t mean they’re not valuable.

When in doubt about the authenticity and value of any jewelry items, it is best to have a professional gemologist evaluate and thoroughly look them over. You may just be amazed by the treasures you never knew you had.

Yingjia Puk

Yingjia Puk

Yingjia is a GIA certified graduate gemologist and holds a BA from New York University She has also worked extensively with jewelry as an editor.


©2011-2022 Worthy, Inc. All rights reserved.
Worthy, Inc. operates from 20 W 37 St., 12th Floor, New York, NY 10018