Selling Diamond Jewelry in Columbus Ohio

Last updated: December 10, 2020
Sell Diamond Jewelry in Columbus, Ohio
A fair market price means not getting a penny less than the value the market agrees upon. It’s a product of competition, meaning there must be others buying and selling as well, and everyone wants the best price they can possibly get. There is an equal push for every pull. For jewelry, this notion has traditionally operated in the opposite way – after all, how many times has a jeweler ever given an offer that made you want to sell your precious bracelet or ring? How many jewelers inquire about purchasing used items from their customers at all? Almost none. It has always been that those who want to sell their used jewelry must be the ones to approach first before most likely being met with an unreasonably low offer.

Now, residents of Columbus have several better alternatives. With Worthy, anyone can sell their used diamond jewelry online, and gain access to a broad network of buyers. Our online platform enables a person to put their piece up for auction online in front of the most relevant and interested parties, and to watch them bid competitively for their precious items. This method presents an extraordinary way to get the fair market price from the market itself.

Where Can You Sell Jewelry in Columbus?

There are many places that one can go to sell their precious old heirlooms, gifts from an ex, or jewelry that simply is no longer in fashion. While the hunt used to involve a lot of legwork, visits to many jewelers and often disappointment, Worthy is changing the game.
Local Columbus Jeweler: Going to a pawn shop, dealer, or even a high-end jewelry boutique will likely result in the same outcome. These places make their money one of two ways: by selling new jewelry that has been marked up, or old jewelry that they bought for pennies on the dollar. They get away with this because there is low demand in the local market, and little stopping them from offering prices just above rock bottom.
Online: At, we will guide you through the entire unique process of selling your jewelry online. At the beginning, we will just ask for a bit of information on your item, then we will help you ship it to our facilities where it will be graded, photographed and put in our system. We cover all costs and take full responsibility for your item, guaranteeing its integrity and your complete control at every step of the process.
Using Worthy was so easy, I felt very comfortable.
Sierra Fein · Happy Client

The City of Columbus

Columbus is a classic Midwestern city, and a flag-waving member of America’s heartland. Its citizens are proud to take part in the pastimes that contribute most to the colorful culture of the States, and accordingly there is a tangible energy that buzzes through the streets during holidays and other celebrations. As Ohio’s capital city, Columbus is a natural destination for food, beer, art, music, and most importantly: sports.
Few things can rile up the city’s residents as much as a Columbus Blue Jackets game. The city is a veritable epicenter of sporting events, and hosts an impressive number of venues including their NHL team’s Nationwide Arena, the 105,000-seat Ohio Stadium, and the Columbus Crew Soccer Club’s Mapfre Stadium – which was the first purpose-built arena exclusively for soccer in the country. Columbus is also home to one of the most successful NCAA programs in the country, with the city’s Ohio State University Buckeyes consistently a source of funding and support for a countless number of successful varsity teams.  
The rivalries aren’t restricted to the field however. When not cheering their favorite team, Columbus’ citizens are known to be competitive about the places in which they dine and drink as well. The city’s “Best Of” lists are a serious point of contention among Columbusites, and when Graeter’s usurped Jeni’s Splendid Ice Cream as the city’s number one scoop, it was considered a stunning upset. Among endless craft breweries, gastropubs and fine dining establishments, Columbus can satisfy any culinary palate.

Sell Diamond Jewelry Columbus
Those looking for jewelry experience no shortage of available options. There are a plethora of pawn shops, jewelry buyers and sellers, jewelry shops and wholesalers for those looking to buy or to sell jewelry in Columbus. However, the best choice is a new one; log on to  and get more to show for your efforts.

How to Sell Jewelry Online with Worthy:

  1. Get Trending Price – Describe your diamond jewelry, and Worthy will show you how similar items auctioned online to give you an idea of its value.
  2. Schedule a FedEx pickup – Worthy will prepare a FedEx shipping label for your jewelry. Your jewelry will be fully insured against theft, loss or damage while in transit to our headquarters.
  3. Grading & Auction Preparation of Your Jewelry – All jewelry on the Worthy auction platform is graded at GSI labs or at GIA. This results in an e-report. Next, the jewelry will be photographed in high definition from every possible angle. This provides potential buyers with all the information they need to make an informed decision during the auction process.
  4. The Auction - Worthy invites interested jewelry buyers to place bids on your high-end jewelry. The GIA or GSI report presents buyers with the technical specifications of your jewelry. During the auction, jewelry sellers can watch the auction map live to see the bids coming in.
  5. Claim Your Payment – if the highest bid meets or exceeds the minimum reserve price set for your jewelry, you will get paid ASAP. If not, you may request to have your jewelry returned to your address free of charge.

Reasons to Trust Worthy

Worthy works hard to earn and keep your confidence because we understand that we have been entrusted to care for some items with immense meaning and value. As such, there are many reasons to work with us rather than going it alone or returning to the old method of selling.
Objectivity: The idea of intrinsic value is crucial to our model of business. While any jeweler is capable of eyeballing a diamond and throwing out a number, we will never assign a value to your item. We let the piece itself do the talking. By taking advantage of our free GIA or GSI grading, photography and more, potential bidders will be able to build a greater understanding of an item's inherent value. Our buyers love our scientific approach, and bid with confidence every time.
Transparency: There is never a moment where one will wonder what is happening with the jewelry they have sent to us. Customers are always kept abreast of the latest developments during each stage of the process, from shipping and location, to grading results, pricing information, current bids and more.
Security: We take the necessary steps to ensure that no customer’s items are ever at risk. We accomplish this by paying for insured FedEx shipping no matter where an item is coming from or going to while putting our guarantee on each expensive item under our care. We have extensive physical and digital security measures in place to keep your valuable items and information safe.


If you are looking to sell estate jewelry in Columbus, there are a few good options available. There are some reputable estate jewelry buyers in Columbus however you may benefit even more by  selling your estate jewelry from the comfort of your own home on The team at Worthy will assist you in understanding the value of your estate jewelry and selling it with ease.

Recently Sold From Columbus:

Worthy’s Professional Buyers

Can you trust the buyers who are a part of our network? Yes, absolutely. Worthy puts each potential buyer through an intense vetting process, which is designed to test them on professionalism, history in the industry, valuation, and, of course, solvency. These key factors are all necessary to confirm that buyers are qualified, reliable, and can place winning bids with confidence.
The items that bidders participating in our auction platform like to see typically includes a variety of diamond jewelry. This could mean diamond bracelets, engagement rings, necklaces, earrings and more. There are also those who seek watches, loose precious stones and gems, or just about any quality piece available. Our system makes it easy to find the buyers who are looking for an item like yours immediately, helping them to offer a price that is well worth your time.
Check out to get started, or alternatively, call us to speak to a member of our team who will help navigate the process with you face-to-face.

Share this page: