1 (888) 222-0208

Selling Tiffany Jewelry Online Made Easy

Last updated: February 11, 2020
sell Tiffany jewelry
Selling pre-owned Tiffany & Co. jewelry is simple and worth it. Pieces you have outgrown and no longer want can easily become another person’s favorites. And why not? Tiffany & Co. jewelry is simple and exquisite, making it a true classic that will always be sought after, both new and at resale, holding its value very well.

The Iconic Brand of Tiffany & Co.

While many immediately think of a light blue ring box when they hear the name “Tiffany & Co.”, that is not exactly where the brand began. The company was founded in 1837 by partners Charles Lewis Tiffany and John B. Young. At its founding, Tiffany & Co. was a “stationery and fancy goods emporium” in New York City. The original shop was called Tiffany, Young, and Ellis, and offered a wide variety of items including stationery, porcelain, crystal, and artwork, some of which is still sold at the store today. The company’s name was abbreviated to Tiffany & Company in 1853. At the same time, Charles Tiffany took the reins and remodeled the store.

Over the course of the 20th century, Tiffany & Co. became a magnet for some of the biggest jewelry designers, including Jean Schlumberger, Paloma Picasso, Elsa Peretti, and even the watchmaking experts and Patek Philippe. Tiffany jewelry has been sold at stores in major international cities. This prestigious line of jewelry includes almost everything imaginable; from classic earrings, luxurious bracelets and cocktail rings to gorgeous diamond engagement rings.

Tiffany Engagement Rings

Tiffany engagement rings are known for their clean, classic simplicity showing off a flawless sparkling stone. Tiffany prides itself on cutting their diamonds to maximize their brilliance, and the company’s designers are backed by more than 175 years of design heritage that inspire modern masterpieces. Because of their captivating designs and quality craftsmanship, Tiffany engagement rings are timeless symbols that maintain their value through the years. Tiffany engagement ring resale value is typically very high, so long as the ring is in good to excellent condition. Prices are always dependent on demand, and it’s no surprise that these beautiful rings are always top sellers.

Recently Auctioned Tiffany Rings:


Why Sell Your Tiffany & Co. Jewelry?

Many people sell Tiffany & Co. jewelry pieces and use the money to buy themselves jewelry that fits their current style, put money towards education, make a different luxury purchase, or even to start an investment fund.


Recent Tiffany Jewelry Deals:


Resale Value of Branded Jewelry

In the mid 2010s, McKinsey & Company released a report on the jewelry industry, stating that branded jewelry is becoming more and more popular with each passing year. The report predicts that by 2020, branded jewelry will make up 30-40 percent of the market. While that does seem like a big chunk, branded jewelry is still relatively rare and marketplace demand continues to drive up the price. High-end brands like Tiffany & Co., Van Cleef & Arpels, and Cartier have, over many years, maintaining a high standard of excellence, increasing their popularity and their value.

Another element to the price of branded jewelry is the quality of materials used, including exceptional diamonds and other notable gemstones, unique provenance, or popular vintage style features can contribute to value. Other factors including condition, the jewelry’s age, and design, and of course, the quality of the mounting and any side stones are considered as well.

Since Tiffany jewelry resale value performs better in comparison to non-branded jewelry, our professional buyers are highly attracted by it, and this ultimately results in higher bids. Therefore antique, vintage and contemporary Tiffany jewelry continues to offer high resale value in our marketplace.


Where To Sell Tiffany & Co. Jewelry

While Tiffany & Co. has excellent customer service, buying back diamond jewelry is not something they do, unless it has been 30 days or less since the original sale. If you are looking to sell your Tiffany & Co. jewelry, there are various options, some local and some online.

Local jewelry stores, consignment shops, and pawn shops may seem like a nearby, convenient way to sell your jewelry, however, these options do not often yield fair market prices. Local jewelers cannot afford to buy pre-owned jewelry at the original sale price while consignment and pawn shops depend on the right foot traffic in order for items to sell for a high price.

Online options like eBay don’t require the legwork and Tiffany & Co. jewelry can be sold from your home. The downside of eBay is that you will be one of a million-plus users looking to sell jewelry without experts to help you determine the true value and no way make sure your piece gets the attention of buyers who know and are able to buy at fair market price.

Worthy combines the best of both worlds, allowing you to sell Tiffany & Co. jewelry from the comfort of your home, providing guidance in determining a fair market price, and making sure your Tiffany & Co. jewelry is presented to qualified buyers ready to buy at good prices.


Benefits of Selling Tiffany & Co. Jewelry With Worthy

  • Best price. The internet allows you to reach far and wide, ensuring that your item is seen by multiple professional buyers, and ensuring that you will receive the best price as multiple people bid.
  • Fast, simple process. We help you sell your fine jewelry on a platform that’s fair, fast, and convenient. All gemstone grading, jewelry cleaning, professional photography, and marketing expertise are included in every sale.
  • Simply schedule FedEx pickup and we’ll handle the rest, ultimately offering your jewelry to our worldwide network of professional jewelry buyers, who can place bids based on experience and knowledge of your item and the greater market.
  • Complimentary GIA grading report. Understanding what you have is the key to obtaining a fair price for your jewelry.
  • Work with your own account manager. Your expert Worthy account executive offers discreet and private service and is available by chat, phone or email depending on your preference to answer any questions and keep you updated on the auction as it progresses.
  • worthy Michelle review engagement ring
    Great experience! I would definitely recommend Worthy to everyone!

    Michelle Erhard Kindle · Bluffdale, Utah

    Michelle Sold
    A Diamond Ring
    worthy sell engagement ring

    How Do We Get You The Best Price When Selling Your Tiffany & Co. Jewelry?

  • Our unique auction platform, getting multiple competing offers.
  • Professional photographs and descriptions tailored to sell Tiffany jewelry.
  • GIA grading reports at no cost to you.
  • Reputations as experts, the best in our field, led by former Tiffany & Co. Chief Gemologist, Roy Albers.
  • Using Worthy was so easy, I felt very comfortable.
    Sierra Fein · Happy Client

    How To Sell Tiffany Jewelry With Worthy

    1. Free Secure Pickup - Describe your valuable and schedule a secure shipment. Your item will be shipped to our offices via FedEx and is insured for up to $100,000 by Lloyds of London.

    2. We Do All The Work - Once your item arrives at our offices, it is screened and put into our secure tracking system.

      • We get your valuable ready for auction by carefully cleaning it and having beauty shots taken by professional photographers.

      • Then it’s off to be graded by an industry-leading diamond lab like GIA, GSI, or IGI. Watches are inspected by Central Watch in NYC.

      • Now it’s time to create an auction listing, complete with the lab grading and beauty shot.

      • Set your reserve price, either by using our recommended price guarantee or setting a manual reserve price.

      • Start your auction!

    3. Get paid - As offers from vetted professionals come in, you decide what offer to choose. Once the auction has concluded, you will receive the final sale amount minus our commission. Choose a payment method and get paid fast.

    100% Seller Protection
    We only trust the best diamond grading lab in the world, GIA, to grade valuables prior to auction. Diamonds sold with GIA grading reports are considered more valuable and can command higher prices.
    More About Our Seller Protection Policy.


    Share this page: