Skip to content
Sell Tiffany & Co. Jewelry Online for the Best Price
Selling your Tiffany & Co. jewelry is simple and worth it when you sell with Worthy
tiffany page header
Last updated: January 30, 2024

Pieces of Tiffany jewelry you have outgrown and no longer want can easily become another person’s favorites—and for a price that will make everyone happy. Because Tiffany jewelry is simple, exquisite, and holds its value very well, it’s a true classic that will always be sought after, both new and at resale.

If you’re considering selling some of your Tiffany & Co. pieces, Worthy can help. Selling Tiffany jewelry online has never been easier due to our multiple-buyer auction platform that will ensure your jewelry pieces fetch the highest and most competitive price possible.

Recently Sold Tiffany Jewelry

Does Tiffany Jewelry Have Resale Value?

tiffany engagement ring in box

1.10 ct. Oval Cut Halo Tiffany & Co. Ring. Sold for $5,011.

Tiffany engagement rings are known for their clean, classic simplicity and for showing off a flawless, sparkling stone. The company prides itself on cutting its diamonds to maximize their brilliance. And their designers are backed by more than 175 years of design heritage that inspire modern masterpieces.

Because Tiffany Jewelry is so popular and classic, it is always in demand and has strong resale value. Although you won’t get close to retail value for your pre-owned Tiffany jewelry, it’s still worth quite a lot on the resale market.

Due to their captivating designs and quality craftsmanship, Tiffany engagement rings are timeless symbols that maintain their value through the years. For example, the diamonds are cut by master artisans in the trade with a great deal of experience. For another thing, Tiffany diamonds are 100% conflict-free. This means they source their diamonds ethically in search of the highest quality diamonds from all around the world.

Prices are always dependent on demand, and it’s no surprise that Tiffany’s beautiful engagement rings are always top sellers.

gia logo

World-Class Grading Labs

We put our trust in the best diamond grading labs in the world, such as the GIA and IGI, to grade items prior to auction. Diamonds and gemstones sold with grading reports from these top labsare considered more valuable and can command higher prices.

igi logo

Why Sell Your Preowned Tiffany & Co. Jewelry

There are many different reasons why people sell their Tiffany jewelry. For starters, when a marriage ends, many people no longer want to hold onto a piece of jewelry with painful memories attached or that just is no longer relevant. Others may have inherited a diamond ring that doesn’t fit their personal style or taste. Still others may be ready to sell a Tiffany ring to upgrade to an even better piece.

No matter why a person sells their Tiffany jewelry, there are many different things they can do with the money. For instance, they might put the money towards education, make a different luxury fashion purchase, take a fancy vacation, or even start an investment fund.

Whatever a person’s reason for selling their Tiffany jewelry, they will likely wonder where the best place to sell their piece is. In the next section, we will look at some options to and explain why Worthy is the best place to sell your Tiffany diamond.

Tiffany & Co. ELSA PERETTI Diamond Necklace

Tiffany & Co. Elsa Peretti Diamond Necklace. Sold for $10,073.

Where You Can Sell Your Tiffany & Co. Jewelry?

Sell Back to Tiffany’s

Many people who want to sell a piece of Tiffany jewelry wonder if Tiffany will buy back their own items. While Tiffany & Co. has excellent customer service, they will only accept returns on their merchandise within 30 days and in exchange for store credit or another item. But if you are looking to resell your pre-owned Tiffany jewelry, there are various other brick and mortar and online options.

Local Jewelers, Consignment, and Pawn Shops

Local jewelry stores, consignment shops, and pawn shops may seem like a convenient way to sell your jewelry. However, these options very rarely yield fair market prices. Local jewelers cannot afford to buy pre-owned jewelry at market rates so that they can pay for their overhead expenses and earn a profit, Consignment and pawn shops are both in a similar situation due to their physical business model.

Online Options

Online options like eBay don’t require much legwork, and your Tiffany jewelry can be sold from your home. But the downside to sites like eBay, craigslist, or Facebook marketplace is that you will be one of many sellers competing to move their items—and you’ll have no way to make sure your piece gets the attention of buyers who know and can buy at fair market price.

For these reasons, we created Worthy with the goal of being the best place to sell your Tiffany jewelry. In what follows, you’ll learn why Worthy makes it easy, fast, and safe to sell your jewelry online for the highest prices on the market.

lloyds of london

Luxury Item Protection

Worthy provides full insurance coverage for every shipment. We trust Lloyd’s of London, a global leader in insurance since 1688, to protect all valuables auctioned on our platform.

Why  Worthy is the Best Place to Sell Your Tiffany Jewelry

Every day, Worthy strives to be the best place to sell Tiffany jewelry. We offer a unique solution by working with and for sellers like you to find the perfect buyer in our exclusive buyers network. This ensures we get you the best deal for your diamond jewelry easily, quickly, and at no cost to you.

Our approach to helping you sell your Tiffany jewelry is unique in many ways. For example, Worthy offers our sellers:

A Fast, Simple Process

We help you sell your fine jewelry on a platform that’s fair, fast, and convenient. Diamond grading, jewelry cleaning, professional photography, and marketing expertise are all included at no cost to you.

A Free Diamond Grading Report

We have your diamond graded by GIA or an equally reputable service so you know the true value of your diamond. A grading report is not an appraisal with a dollar amount, but tells you everything you need to know about the factors that will determine your stone’s unique value.

Personal Account Manager

Your expert Worthy account executive offers discreet and private service and is available by chat, phone, or email, depending on your preference. They will be happy to answer any questions and keep you updated on the auction as it progresses.

Convenience & Security

If your diamond jewelry qualifies for our service, we supply you with free and fully insured FedEx shipping to our headquarters in New York. We handle everything from photography to generating buyer interest while you kick batch and watch the bids roll in on Worthy’s online platform.

Our Buyer Network

Our worldwide network of professional jewelry buyers, who can place bids based on experience and knowledge of your item and the greater market.

The Best Price on the Market

Most importantly, our mission is to get you the best price for your diamond Tiffany jewelry. Our competitive auction system generates the demand that will drive your diamond’s price up to 2 or 3 times as much as you can usually get elsewhere in the marketplace. It’s why our many thousands of happy customers have been happy to recommend Worthy to their friends and family since we opened in 2014.

How to Sell Tiffany Jewelry with Worthy

Tiffany & Co.

1 Prep for sale

Tiffany & Co.

2 Auction online

Tiffany & Co.

3 Get paid

  1. Tell us about your item – answer a few basic questions about your Tiffany & Co. jewelry for our experts to review. 
  2. Schedule shipping – we take care of shipping your item to our offices safely and securely. All you need to do is schedule a FedEx pickup from your home, or drop-off at a convenient FedEx location.
  3. Prepare for sale – our team of experts professionally cleans, examines, and photographs your Tiffany & Co. jewelry. Then it is sent to a professional lab for 3rd party grading. 
  4. Online auction – working with a dedicated auction manager, you set a reserve price for your online auction and watch the offers for your Tiffany & Co. jewelry roll in.
  5. Get paid – once your item is sold, you’ll get the final sale amount sent to you through your preferred payment method. 

Sell Your Tiffany & Co. Jewelry with Worthy Today

Worthy is the best place to sell your Tiffany jewelry. If you don’t believe us, check out our thousands of satisfied, 5-star customer reviews. If you have any questions or would like more information, get in touch with our team who would be delighted to help you. We’re looking forward to helping you get the best price possible for your diamond jewelry. If you’re ready to start selling your Tiffany ring, click the button below to begin the process.

Last updated: January 30, 2024