Selling Diamond Jewelry in Denver

Last updated: December 10, 2020
Sell Diamond Jewelry in Denver Colorado
While jewelry is a wonderful gift to receive, after some time you may feel that the presents you got are no longer as “you” as they once were. Perhaps the gift giver is someone you don’t want to think about. No matter the reason, sometimes old jewelry needs to be sold. But how? Traditionally, pawn shops or consignment stores were people’s first choice when it came to selling their valuables. These options, however, tend not to yield as much profit as sellers would like. Worthy is an online auction platform specializing in diamond jewelry. By selling to verified diamond buyers, we get high, true to market bids on your items. And everything can be done from the comfort of your home. Fast, simple, secure.


When looking to sell jewelry in Denver, you'll want to go for an easy and trustworthy alternative. But you’ll also want to be sure that you get a fair market price. There are several options available to sell your jewelry locally in Denver. But their level of transparency and ability to provide a fair price isn't the same for all of them.    

Local Denver jeweler - For starters, you can go to a local jewelry store near you, to a pawn shop, or to diamond buyers. The local jewelry store near you may be a great place to get an appraisal, but it’s not necessarily the best place to get a fair market price. Local jewelers rely on markup to make their profits, and this is the reason they buy low and sell high.

Online - Another way to sell diamond jewelry in Denver is online, from the comfort of your home. Worthy is an online auction house for diamond jewelry. We provide you with a free estimate, a free and insured FedEx shipping of your item to our headquarters in New York City, and a complimentary GIA or GSI grading. Via our competitive auction platform, we connect you with a wide network of professional buyers, ensuring a fair market value for your item. And if you decide not to sell your jewelry online, we will have it safely returned to your address, at no cost to you.  .  
bbb a+
100% Seller Protection
Consumer confidence is of utmost importance to us here at Worthy. That is why, one of our first steps was to be accredited and graded by the BBB. Like them, we uphold the value in transparency, honesty, and legitimate business practices.
More About Our Seller Protection Policy.

How Does the Worthy Auction Process Work?

  1. Get a Trending Price – describe your diamond jewelry to us and we conduct all necessary market research to determine the trending price for your jewelry.
  2. Schedule a FedEx Pickup – we provide a prepaid FedEx shipping label for you. Your diamond jewelry is fully insured while it is in transit to our headquarters in New York.
  3. Grading & Auction Preparation – all jewelry items on our platform are graded by GIA or GSI labs. Once the e-report is generated, we share this information with jewelry buyers on our platform. We also take professional photographs of your jewelry to give buyers as much information as they need to bid on your jewelry.
  4. The Auction – Jewelry buyers are invited to bid on your item. Buyers are able to learn about your item’s specifications in the diamond grading report. While the auction is underway, jewelry sellers can watch the auction map in real time to watch the bids coming in.
  5. Get Paid – The bid that meets or exceeds the reserve price of your jewelry is the one that seals the deal. We guarantee prompt payment, and if you decide not to sell we will return the jewelry to you free of charge.


If you are looking to sell estate jewelry in Denver, there are a few good options available. There are some reputable estate jewelry buyers in Denver however you may benefit even more by selling your estate jewelry from the comfort of your own home on Worthy. The success advocates at Worthy will assist you in understanding the value of your estate jewelry and selling it with ease.


Denver is the capital and most populous municipality in the state of Colorado. Denver’s official elevation is exactly one mile above sea level, making it the highest major city in the United States. Other interesting records make Denver the nation's most educated city with the highest percentage of college graduates. Denver is also home to the longest continuous street in America, Colfax Avenue, known as the “Gateway to the Rockies.”

On a different note (a sparklier one!), Denver is located only 2 hours away from Kelsey Lake, where the namesake diamond mine used to operate until 2001. Located near the Wyoming border, the Kelsey Lake Diamond Mine was, at the time it operated, the only modern diamond mine in the United States. The Kelsey Lake mine produce some large diamonds, like the “Colorado Diamond”, found in 1996. The 28.3 CT yellow stone was the largest diamond found in that mine and the fifth-largest diamond found in North America.

Sell Diamond Jewelry in Denver


There are many reasons to sell jewelry, but in all cases, you will want to get the best price. The local jewelry store near you limits your ability to get a higher price since there is limited competition for your jewelry. At Worthy, the competitive auction facilitates a fair market price for your item. The complimentary GIA and GSI diamond grading reports, professional photographs and detailed descriptions of your piece enhance buyer’s trust, encouraging them to place higher bids at auction.

We understand that it is not always easy to part with sentimental pieces of jewelry. That’s why we go to great lengths to ensure a hassle-free process, giving you peace of mind when easily selling your diamond jewelry directly with us via our online auction platform.

Recently Sold Denver Items:


We take pride in working with the very best in the industry to provide a secure and transparent process. From the free and fully insured FedEx shipping to the GIA and GSI diamond grading reports, we don’t cut corners where security and objectivity are concerned. You can rest assured that your item is fully insured against loss, damage, or theft from the time it leaves your possession until the time it is sold to the final buyer.

Transparency is of utmost importance for us, that is why we make sure you stay in the loop the whole time by giving you access to watch the auction unfold in real time. Unlike local jewelers, we don’t assign a price tag to your jewelry. Instead, we have it graded by the world’s top gemological labs, and our network of professional buyers place their bids based on the grading report. Ultimately, we bring your piece’s true market value to light, at no risk to you.

We are A+ rated by the Better Business Bureau (BBB) and we hold a Secondhand Dealer License issued by The New York City Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA). Our clients have shared their experience using our platform, and you can hear them here.

Using Worthy was so easy, I felt very comfortable.
Sierra Fein · Happy Client

WORTHY's professional jewelry BUYERS

Our jewelry buyers are strictly vetted to ensure that they are trustworthy. We require professional references of all our jewelry buyers. All our buyers are currently involved in the jewelry industry at some level and they must understand the jewelry market. Our buyers know that all bids placed on the auction platform are legally binding. Once a bid is made, it cannot be retracted.

When you sell jewelry in Denver, Colorado, it’s important to understand what jewelry buyers out there are interested in. Fortunately, buyers’ preferences are wide-ranging. At Worthy, you can sell engagement rings, loose diamonds, wedding rings, watches, and other high-end jewelry pieces to buyers. You can tap into a wide network of buyers that is not restricted to Denver alone – the network spans far and wide. For more information on the items currently in demand, you can get in touch with our customer support.

Share this page: