The Complete Guide for Selling Your Diamond Jewelry in Pittsburgh

Last updated: December 10, 2020
Sell Diamond Jewelry in PittsburghJewelry has a habit of being acquired and then sitting in a drawer or armoire for decades. Many pieces seemed destined to be a beautiful gift once, a great accessory for an outfit perhaps a handful of times, and then a sparkly closet-dweller for the remainder of its owner’s life. In fact, part of the reason diamonds look so good in the store window is that seeing them outside a dusty velvet box constitutes a special occasion!
While some represent precious memories or family heirlooms, savvy owners in Pittsburgh recognize that several items in their jewelry collection could be sold with little remorse. The proceeds could even go towards much more useful endeavors. However, they may also recognize that the jewelry market is notoriously unforgiving to resellers, and that traditionally, it has been difficult to get anywhere close to the original retail price. This notion is so ingrained that many people don’t even try.

However, this is no longer the case. While those looking to sell their diamonds were previously restricted to local, Worthy offers the option of selling jewelry to a global network of buyers.  This means that everyone can now get significantly better prices when they sell their jewelry at  a fraction of the effort.

Where Can I Sell My Jewelry in Pittsburgh?

A revitalized jewelry market is creating better opportunities for resellers looking to get a great price on their old jewelry. No more are customers limited to “We Buy Gold” locations or seedy pawn shops. A whole new market, and a plethora of options are now available.
Local Pittsburgh Jeweler -  Dealers in Pittsburgh have little incentive to buy jewelry back from customers. It is not necessarily profitable for them to pay a competitive price for old jewelry when they can simply sell what they have for a bigger markup. It is possible to find a reasonable price, but this requires a thorough search and time spent trekking from shop to shop, hunting for the best estimate.
Online–  If you want to sell your jewelry yourself from the comfort of home, head over to and we will handle it for you. Here we ask you to describe your diamond jewelry and then use this information to provide you with a free estimate. We also offer GIA grading, a professional photo shoot and free shipping, which helps to ensure that the audience of hundreds of diamond buyers competing for your jewelry will give the very best price.
Using Worthy was so easy, I felt very comfortable.
Sierra Fein · Happy Client

Precious Gems and Jewelry in Pittsburgh

Known as both “The Steel City” and “The City of Bridges”, Pittsburgh is a bustling metropolis in Pennsylvania with a storied history. Over 446 bridges, 30 skyscrapers in the downtown district, pre-revolutionary fortifications and more exemplify the longevity and pride with which Pittsburgh builders work. Melding these industrial inclinations with a strong patriotic spirit, Pittsburgh also became the home of Rosie the Riveter in 1942 thanks to resident artist J. Howard Miller. Rosie was the symbol of an important national work effort that helped propel the United States and its allies to victory during World War II. Clearly, Pittsburghers have much to be proud of.

Precious Gems and Jewelry in Pittsburgh
Ferris wheel inventor George W. Ferris may have never built his world-famous invention had he not had access to the metal-manipulating talents in his native city, and other inventors have also taken advantage of Pittsburgh’s industrious spirit. George Blaisdell created the Zippo Lighter there in 1932, taken from the name “zipper”, which had just been patented nearby.
Steel is not the only metal that Pittsburgh is known for however. Adeptness at molding precious metals as well resulted in a successful local jewelry market, which originated in Market Square. Once known as Diamond Alley, this area of the city was the destination for imported liquor, livery, fur, candles, printers and of course, precious gems and metals. Today, the industry has flourished, and presents those who are looking to get a great price on their diamond necklace or sapphire earrings with many options.

Getting the Best Price on Your Jewelry in Pittsburgh

Whether to pay for other expenses, expel bad memories of an ex or simply because you’d rather have cash, there is no reason to compromise when it comes to getting a fair price on your jewelry. This may be difficult in a local environment, where competition and demand are limited to the immediate area. By going to the Worthy  platform yourself, you can put your unique pieces in front of hundreds of competing buyers who can review professional photos, GIA grading and more.

Worthy covers all costs, including shipping, grading, photography and more to ensure that the process is as smooth as possible. You can watch the bidding for your jewelry live on, and maintain control over the sale. If the price is not progressing towards your minimum at an adequate pace, you can always request the return of your item, or organize another sale.

Recently Auctioned Items:


If you are looking to sell estate jewelry in Pittsburgh, there are a few good options available. There are some reputable estate jewelry buyers in Pittsburgh however you may benefit even more by selling your estate jewelry from the comfort of your own home on The success advocates at Worthy will assist you in understanding the value of your estate jewelry and selling it with ease.

How Does the Worthy Auction Process Work?

  1. Get Your Free Estimate Describe your diamond jewelry, and Worthy will conduct market research to determine the price of similar items auctioned online. We will then provide you with this information.
  2. Schedule a FedEx pickup – Worthy will prepare a FedEx shipping label for your jewelry. Your jewelry will fully insured against theft, loss or damage while in transit to our headquarters.
  3. Grading & Auction Preparation of Your Jewelry – All jewelry on the Worthy auction platform is graded at GSI labs or at GIA. This results in an e-report. Next, the jewelry will be photographed in high definition from every possible angle. This provides potential buyers with all the information they need to make an informed decision during the auction process.
  4. The Auction Process – Worthy invites interested jewelry buyers to place bids on your high-end jewelry. The GIA or GSI report presents buyers with the technical specifications of your jewelry. During the auction, jewelry owners can watch the auction map live to see the bids arrive in real-time.
  5. Claim Your Payment – If the highest bid meets or exceeds the minimum reserve price set for your jewelry, you will get paid immediately. If not, you reserve the right to have your jewelry returned to your address, free of charge.

Why Should I Sell My Jewelry with Worthy?

In an industry with sky-high competition, and especially one that must handle objects of immense value, Worthy stays at the top by operating only at the highest possible standards. We ensure security, transparency and objectivity in our relationships with customers, and work tirelessly to provide them the best possible market price for their jewelry. Part of this guarantee comes from the fact that we only work with the most trusted jewelers in our buyers network.
Security –  Worthy fully insures all shipped packages and follows airtight security measures when handling valuable items. We take your trust seriously, and shoulder the entire burden of keeping your jewelry secure.
Transparency – Selling online, or letting others manage the sale of your precious jewelry can be uncomfortable. It’s normal to feel a lack of control, and Worthy remedies this by making the process as visible as possible. You will always know the location and status of your item, who is looking at it, all active bidders, offers and more.
Objectivity – Selling your jewelry locally will not always get you the best price, because the business interests of any single dealer naturally deter them from offering market value for your precious valuables. These dealers entertain many other considerations besides the price they think they can receive for these items. We seek to introduce a more objective system, based on the inherent value of a diamond according to its GIA or GSI grade. This means that buyers have a reliable system for determining value and can confidently extend appropriate offers.
worthy review engagement ring
Great website, super fast sale and great people to work with.

Francesca Ruini · Yarmouth Port, Massachusetts

Francesca Sold
A Diamond Ring
worthy sell engagement ring

Can I Trust Worthy Jewelry Buyers?

All the buyers in our network go through comprehensive screening and vetting processes to ensure that they are reliable, trustworthy and solvent. We request professional references and do our own research, helping customers feel confident that all parties they will encounter have been Worthy-approved.
Our platform goes a long way to protecting the integrity of the auction process, and requires that all buyers have the money matching their corresponding bids. Moreover, a placed bid is a legally-binding obligation to follow through on the purchase, a guarantee that lends every seller peace of mind.
bbb a+
100% Seller Protection
Consumer confidence is of utmost importance to us here at Worthy. That is why, one of our first steps was to be accredited and graded by the BBB. Like them, we uphold the value in transparency, honesty, and legitimate business practices.
More About Our Seller Protection Policy.

The buyers who work with us are experts in their trade, and have an incentive to use their knowledge to offer the most appropriate prices on items they desire. Most popular on Worthy are diamond engagement rings, diamond wedding rings, diamond bracelets, diamond earrings, diamond necklaces and similar pieces. We prefer diamonds to be 0.5 carats or more, but strive to provide relevant feedback and valuation on anything brought to us.
Our buyers often are only interested in certain kinds of jewelry, and with the Worthy platform it’s a simple matter to customize the settings to display only the most relevant items. Additionally, once enough information has been provided, the Worthy team uses this data to reach out to likely buyers and stir interest. Buyers then have between 5 and 7 days to place their bids, during which time you are updated on how the sale is progressing. This method is proven to procure the very best prices.

Share this page: